Do you want the Internet to be an extension of your existing offline relationships, or to be separate from your offline life? I think these are two totally different modes for using the Internet, and most people are in the first group.
I’ve found my relationships are healthier when I keep my offline-first relationships offline (e.g. not following each other on Facebook or Instagram) — following someone’s Instagram makes it feel like I know what’s going on with them without interacting. Following offline friends on social media can reduce what used to be normal friendships into parasocial relationships.
Social media made me feel like I had no excuse to ping someone to catch up because I’d already seen everything they’d been doing, so I needed some reason to call. It’s also weird the other way, when someone followed me on Instagram or whatever, and I didn’t know what they’d already seen from my posts so I didn’t know what to talk about, what they already knew. (I find the social code for this type of interaction tricky anyway.)
I suspect bringing offline relationships online is responsible for a lot of the loneliness people feel — social media looks like you have all these friends… but no one you could ask to feed your cat while you’re away, because one-to-many broadcasting replaced direct interactions 😿 Essentially, the offline relationship became an online one.
Connecting online changes the dynamic of communicating outside social media. Calling unexpectedly is now frowned upon by anyone under 40, but texting doesn’t offer the same sort of real-time connection.
Social media also keeps us attached to old relationships that would have faded away naturally when they’d run their course, but online friendships are forever — unless one of you makes the decision to manually remove the other 😳 We lose the grace of being able to simply forget about people who aren’t that important to our lives anymore.
See also:
People you know from offline don’t read your blog
Building community out of strangers
Social norms of the IndieWeb: followup from Homebrew Website Club