Label

With the bottom bar being fixed in place, and the post text scrolling underneath it, having to expand the post felt like an extra, unnecessary step.

I'm definitely keeping the hover effects on the SVG icons as I think that a little bit of fun and personality. The idea is not to strip the site of its character but to remove things that make it clumsy. I have to remember to view the site in an incognito window so that I see it as others do, without being logged in.

A feature I'm not sure about (and, admittedly, almost never use myself) is the date picker. I know it doesn't get in the way or cause any usability issues but do I really need it?

Obviously this is not just a blog, rather its own ecosystem with symbiotic relationships between the different parts.

I started pining for the more basic approach of hyblog which behaves a lot like this site used to – albeit with an alternative approach. That's not to say hyblog is better (it's far from perfect and could do with some updates) it's just different and doesn't have all the extra trappings.

Things are in a constant state of flux but features are usually added instead of being removed; everything made more complicated rather than being simplified. Beyond the navigation map and virtual business card (which weren't around long enough to count) the only recent removals have been the /start page and the Garden. ¹

This site is like an old house which new owners remodel and extend such that it becomes a mishmash of styles. Each new room has its own design language and means of construction – it can be a wonder that the whole thing remains standing.

That might be a little melodramatic but you get the idea; behind the façade, things are a bit of a mess.

Walking through the code charts my personal development. The original core is fairly crude, patched up over time with new insights (or better glue). New additions often look like an excuse to use something I've just learnt but without retrofitting what's already there. Consistency is definitely not something you'll find.

This makes me want to go back and rewrite everything – there is so much duplication and extraneous rubbish – but that would be a massive undertaking I just don't have the stomach for.

All aspects of the site can be improved, from the PHP to HTML layout and CSS. Logic in numerous areas could be simplified and a lot more elements reused across pages. Likely months of work that would have to be completed on a clone site with the additional issues that would cause.

Maybe, in the first instance, I just need to go through everything, ask myself if it needs to be there and, hopefully, get some honest answers. What is essential to the site's operation and what is just fluff, added because it looked flashy?

Where are the pain points from the perspective of both a reader and myself? What has been overworked when it really needed to be streamlined?

Don't get me wrong, I am immensely proud of what I've built, I just think it's time to re-evaluate.

¹

I jumped into Postman to spoof a few mentions and managed to get to the bottom of it (the joys of multi-dimensional arrays.) The sending and receiving of webmentions is the easy bit, making sure you get the right information from the source URL, however, is not so simple – especially when there are so many different implementations.

On a side note, Jan-Lukas posted about a web-based, Postman alternative called Hoppscotch that can be self-hosted. Personally, I'm okay with having an account on Postman to save my workspaces but it's always good to have options.